6 March 2019
I had a long and tiring afternoon in the rain, after that underwhelming lunch at the previously-reliable Rijks. As my Rijksmuseum plans were scuppered, I headed out to Haarlem instead. I’m not overly fond of Dutch cemeteries, as they tend to be extremely drab compared to nearly everywhere else in Europe. Nevertheless I strolled through cemetery at Kleverlaan to visit the graves of two Nobel laureates who shared the 1902 Physics prize, who are both buried there.
I was pretty much spent, so I headed back to Amsterdam, glad that my hotel is near Sloterdijk — which is closer to Haarlem. My foot was really killing me so I headed back. I had to do some packing and sorting, as tomorrow I head back across the Atlantic for the last time in a long, long time. No more long-haul travel after this, not for a long while at least…
I eventually had a stroll around the centre but the rain — and the crazy crowds — were just too annoying, so I headed to dinner early. Tonight’s destination, for my final meal on this trip, was Breda. Many people I know rave about the place, so I decided to give it a try. They have no posted menu, so it’s really a surprise.
I got there and was led to a table in the back. I relaxed and they asked how many courses I would like, and I said why not the full tasting with pairing, so that’s one thing done. Then with some nice bread, a selection of amuse arrived.
The cauliflower soup with cockles was not bad, the herring on the crispbread was good though it broke upon even gentle handling, and the sea lettuce and mackered was a bit meh. Then things started to go pretty pear-shaped…
They were moderately busy, but come on, how can you start a meal with a HALF HOUR wait for the first course? By the time it came, I was pretty frustrated — partly as the signal in Amsterdam has been spotty all day and I was sitting there staring at the ceiling… And the first dish at first sight did not give me much confidence…
Haddock, ginger and leek. Tasted far better than it looked, I admit. It actually got better as it went on, the ginger really working well with the fish. Perhaps this evening is gonna work after all. I relaxed a little, and the second dish came surprisingly quickly after that ridiculous wait…
Venison with yolk and oyster mushroom. Sorry about the poor photos, the lighting was very dim inside and my phone was really tired from this trip and was not focusing well… Again, it got better as it went on, working well with a Bulgarian red. The only thing that didn’t work was the mushrooms, as the texture just didn’t fit the rest; I wish they kept it soft. Anyway, so far okay. Then with an Alsace orange wine, which had a wonderful aroma, poured, we have the scallop.
Not bad, but again I think my trip to the Faroe Islands has all but ruined me for scallops. The coral helped this along, as well as dried shaved scallops, and interesting dish. Then a vermentino is poured for the next dish, cream of salsify.
Well, it was wee watery and somewhat acidic, though that worked somewhat here. The truffles also worked once it meshed into the liquid, though this whole dish feels somewhat sloppy. The soup in the amuse was better than this, that’s for sure. Then with another natural wine from Alsace poured, we have the cod.
Drowning in sauce and sundries, when it really doesn’t need it. The cod itself was excellent, but the hard part was getting rid of all the crap. This trend of using whey for acid is rather annoying, to be honest. I thought it worked in a place like Vinland in Portland, Maine, as they use ONLY ingredients from Maine — even during the winter, when options for acid are lacking. This acid was really just intrusive, taking away from the good cod.
At this point the service was beyond a little chaotic. One of the servers seems to be on something, as she’s nearly falling over and spilling wines as she pours nearly each time. It’s a little annoying, and she starts to walk away as she’s finishing the description. When there’s no menu, you really need to do the description much better… This was the case with the next dish, cauliflower.
I’m sorry but this was a total mess. The cauliflower tasted like something between mush and flour, the awful sauce made me wish I had a plate of flour to eat. Wow. I wrote in my notes at the time that this may have been one of the worst dishes I’ve eaten in years… I love cauliflower, and I’ve never had such bad cauliflower in my life. Wow…
Now I’m completely worried, as this dinner is not going well at all. Then for the next dish, sweetbread. But another very sloppy pour of wine and she didn’t even wipe it up…
WTF is going on here…
And the sweetbread…well, same story. The sweetbread itself was done quite well, but the sauce again was an unnecessary acidic attack on the senses. And it’s just SOAKING in it. Whoever is the saucier here really needs to consider how all this goes down… I am not impressed by this at all, not even close. I’m actually hoping this meal all ends soon. Then the final savoury dish, pigeon.
Finally a really good dish! Both parts of the bird was cooked very well; the confit was crispy but soft, perfectly done, and the breast was super soft but had wonderful consistency and taste. The kitchen did themselves very well on this dish. Sadly, a little too late in my mind to rescue this evening.
I was pretty much spent and wanted this to just end soon. I was just hoping for that one server to not spill more wine on my table… Then a pre-dessert.
One of lemon and apple…so acidic, I feel my teeth… Tonight has been a journey through acids frankly, far too much for my palate. Those who love modern Danish cooking would love this place. Sadly, not for me. I struggled through it and the dessert, for which I requested no pairing…
Semifreddo. I’m done. I asked for the bill, and I just wanted to get out of there. I settled up and limped out of the restaurant, heading for the tram to get myself back to Centraal and then to Sloterdijk, so I can put this evening out of my head.
Despite many people I know raving about this place, tonight was a total disappointment. There were so many dishes that just didn’t work for me, being so acidic in such a distracting way. I don’t understand why kitchens feel like they need to overwhelm on each dish and diminish the flavours of the central ingredient. Why not just do each dish with tofu instead so you can show off on the sauces? This is the type of cooking that perplexes me, having eaten at over 100 Michelin-starred restaurants on 4 continents and in 30 countries. Hey, let’s spend a shitload of money on this awesome meat/fish and let’s kill it with cheap whey…
And the service…I understand informality, but frankly the amount of wine spilled tonight by that one server is not just annoying but shows a complete lack of respect for diners. And frankly, I felt absolutely disrespected by this crew here. Just a terrible night overall. Perhaps this is a good time to call it a day on fine dining, this is about a heavy as a straw on the proverbial camel’s back…
Sad, as this is likely my final meal in Europe in a long, long time…and such a bad dining experience to have in my mind…
Breda
Singel 210
Amsterdam, Nederland